Situation 3 · Step 1 of 8
The damage charges are unfair
What this means
Normal wear and tear is the ordinary aging that happens when people live somewhere — like worn carpet in walkways, faded paint, small nail holes, or loose door handles from use.
Actual damage is harm beyond normal use — like a large hole in a wall, burns, broken windows, or pet stains.
Landlords generally cannot charge you for normal wear and tear. Connie will never decide a charge is unlawful for you. The court decides whether each deduction is justified.
Where this comes from (sources)
- Law / court ruleN.J.S.A. 46:8-21.1 Return of deposit within 30 days, itemized list, double the amount wrongfully withheld
- Law / court ruleN.J.S.A. 46:8-21.4 Small Claims handles deposit cases up to $5,000 including penalties
- Law / court ruleR. 6:1-2 (NJ Courts notice, May 11, 2022) Court limits: Small Claims $5,000, Special Civil $20,000 (effective July 1, 2022)
- General infoNJ Courts — Lawsuits $5,000 or less Official Small Claims self-help and forms
- General infoNJ Courts FAQ What happens to the residential security deposit
Sources last reviewed November 2, 2026. Always confirm fees and forms with the court clerk.
What you'll need
- Your full name
- Your current (forwarding) address
- Your phone or email (optional)
- Landlord's legal name
- Landlord's mailing address
- Rental property address
- Date you moved in / lease started
- Date you moved out
- Security deposit you paid
- Amount returned to you
- Did you get a written, itemized list of deductions?
- Date you got the itemized list
- What did the landlord say about why they kept money?
- Docket number (only if a case is already filed)